Hakia - Search for Better Search

Posted by Phil Butler on May 2nd, 2007

Hakia recently initiated “The Search for Better Search” initiative via a focused poll taken from some of Web 2.0's best technical blogs. The results reveal an overwhelming and compelling need for a better search capability. Make no mistake about it; raising the bar for the people at hakia has nothing to do with hype or beating Google really, but about the art of transcendence. The vision there is about elevating the world's expectations and thinking so that search and the Web can transcend to the next level.

For those of you just arriving from another galaxy, hakia is a new search entity based on the vision that search is about meaning derived from context and relevance. To a logical person of a certain type nothing could be simpler really, but the methodology and technology are of course rather much more complicated. Trying to explain hakia's structure has been a difficult task for me; even after conversations with Dr. Riza Berkan, CEO of hakia I was enlightened to the point of illumination but still woefully inept to describe the hakia processes to my friends and readers.

Yesterday I was delighted to chat with Melek Pulatkonak, COO and President of hakia, and once again I was fascinated to talk with a person who is gracious, supremely intelligent and without the slightest inkling of subterfuge. Melek helped me to realize quite a few things I was having some trouble with and, she took an inordinate amount of time answering even the most simplistic questions. I make these points for one purpose only, and that is to illustrate that symbolically everything is important. Excellent people and visions are the gateway to fantastic innovation. When I tell our readers about a brilliant rocket scientist lady who explained patiently a very complex concept, this is a symbol of what our expectations should be at the least.

The results of the Search for Better Search poll reveal a similar symbolic truth. Nearly 65 percent of the technology crowd at the most influential blogs on Web 2.0 revealed their insight for the need of improved search capability and relevance.

The poll was conducted from April 1^stthru April 26^th and is linked along with the commentary to the following sites: Battellemedia; ResourceShelf; GigaOM; TechCrunch; VentureBeat; Read/WriteWeb; and Ars Technica.

Results of the Poll “What do you think a search engine should do?”

39% understand my question the way a human does. (165 votes)
25% bring highly relevant results with semantic precision. (107 votes)
9% give me more control of search options. (39 votes)
7% have user interface that is simple and powerful (31 votes)
5% allow me to participate to rank search results. (21 votes)
5% learn my search behavior in a trusted environment. (20 votes)
4% chat with me to help with my search. (19 votes)
3% provide personalization tools and agents. (12 votes)
3% none of the above! (11 votes)

The Real Issue

Search and the Web as we know them are still in a phase of development. People naturally cling to familiar and useful utilities, places and technologies. We are simultaneously repelled by innovation and change and drawn to the possibilities this dynamic reveals. What we really want is the ability to be understood and helped by the tools we employ. Hakia in their effort at science, art and commercial enterprise (in that order I might add) is addressing one of the most important and complex problems that exist in the next evolution of the Web.

According to Dr. Berkan and Melek the single most important part of the semantic search is the “middle layer” of the technology that is the heart of the attempt to produce a true representation of how the human mind performs searches. In his own words Dr. Berkan provides a much more eloquent explanation of this aspect and why previous attempts have failed to provide a solution.

“A long list of trials has been attempted, all avoiding to change the middle layer technology to enable a full-scale, compromised, semantic natural language processing (NLP). NLP and Web search do not go hand-in-hand unless the middle-ware is invented. Once this obstacle is out of the way, then the possibilities become endless.”

This middle architecture's key element is the QDEX system of data storage gateways to replace the vertical index systems in use so far today. This “top secret” and revolutionary system allows semantically rich data to be processed very rapidly. No vertical index system could ever process semantic data quickly enough to provide a result within milliseconds. Neither Dr. Berkan nor Melek Pulatkonak would represent this aspect of their process as anything beyond advanced technology. These are not secretive people, but they are also not presumptive scientists. I mentioned what I thought of the entire system in both conversations and was answered both times with a kind and knowing laugh.

What you are essentially looking at in the QDEX aspect is at the least a part of what could be considered a brain. Melek will probably kill me for saying this, because she made no claim of such a giant leap from stored, mathematically manipulated data to sentient intelligence. This is why other semantic projects have failed in the past, there was no representation of an element that truly emulated the way a human brain actually functions.

So, how does this “brain” or portion thereof communicate the billions of electrochemical impulses and communications in order to understand in human language a concept or idea? The answer is Ontological Semantics. With OntoSem imposed on our brain (replete with cells) what we have done is infused a system of analysis closely resembling our own reasoning system. OntoSem is constantly researching meaning-based inferencing and reasoning according to the hakia labs description.

What this and the auxiliary capacity of the SemanticRank algorithms essentially approximate or emulate is the way human beings understand language, meaning and ultimately queries from searches. Combine all this with the Dialogue Communications System being developed and the leap from simple computer data base to AI is complete. Hakia is developing what I call “the lower limits” of artificial intelligence. I have been wrong before, but I bet $100 bucks my illustrious friends at hakia will not fault my assumption, especially given my limited scope of interaction with the system.

Actually, being right or wrong is of little import. What is crucially important is for my readers and people everywhere to elevate level of inquiry, thinking, expectations and anticipation of what could be one of the breakthroughs of the 21^st century. Isn't it more interesting to dream and anticipate that these wonderful scientists are endeavoring to create something like I describe for humanity?

I can only encourage you all to visit the hakia labs pages and Ontological Semantics to try yourselves to grasp these complex and fascinating concepts. The poll illuminates the knowing need for something a step up on the evolutionary scale and the people and technology of hakia are demonstrating the probability that we can get there.

My mash up of how to visualize hakia as the beginning of a new search, what does it remind you of? Ok squint if you must then.

Found this post interesting? Consider subscribing to Profy feed.

Send to a Friend

| Stumble It! | Save to del.icio.us | Sphere It |

Tags: AI, arstechnica, battellmedia, beta test, gigaom, Google, hakia, ontological semantics, readwriteweb, resourseshelf, search engine, semantic search, Semantic Web, techcrunch, venturebeat, web 2.0

« Previous post

Trackbacks

(Trackback URL)

Sauja ar referencēm par meklēšanas inovāciju tēmu | Globālais Veikals (Beta 2)

May 8th, 2007 at 10:15 am

[…] Josh Kopelman/Redeye VC: Google - The next vertical search engine? O’Reilly Rader (via Sarah Milstein): Thoughts on the State of Search Don Dodge: What’s new in search technology? Is Google it? Rich Skrenta: How to beat Google, part 1 Information Arbitrage: Domain Expertise: The Key to Next Generation Search David Berkowitz: The Hunt for Search Engine Innovation, Part 1 Richard MacManus/RWW: Interview with Google’s Matt Cutts about Next-Generation Search Phil Butler on Hakia and Powerset Bob Stumpel: SEARCH 2.0 - consolidated Google Operating System: What Has Google Done in Search Lately? […]

CIO log （beta） » Blog Archive » Google 以外的17个搜索引擎创新

May 18th, 2007 at 9:22 am

[…] Josh Kopelman/Redeye VC: Google –下一个垂直搜索引擎？ O’Reilly Rader (via Sarah Milstein): 搜索状况思考 Don Dodge: 搜索技术有什么新意？是Google吗？ Rich Skrenta: 怎样战胜Google（第一部分） Information Arbitrage: 知识领域：下一代搜索的钥匙 David Berkowitz: 寻找搜索创新（第一部分） Richard MacManus/RWW: 关于下一代互联网对Google的Matt Cutts的访谈 Phil Butler谈Hakia和Powerset Bob Stumpel: 搜索2.0–合并 Google操作系统： Google最近在搜索领域作了什么？ […]

little home » Google 以外的17个搜索引擎创新

May 20th, 2007 at 10:12 pm

What, no more cookies? « ThinkingShift	May 25th, 2007 at 10:19 pm
[…] Hakia is also breaking away from the pack by using natural language technology. Search results try to provide a true representation of how the human mind thinks when foraging for information. Hakia does not rely on popularity or indexes like many other search engines. So the power is in the hands of the user and not the search engine. […]

Hakia On Search, Privacy and Trust

June 17th, 2007 at 9:20 am

[…] Hakia On Search, Privacy and Trust Posted by Phil Butler on June 17th, 2007 I was visiting the hakia blog today and found an interesting post by Melek Pulatkonak their COO. Recent privacy problems in the news and particularly Google's "issues" in this area have prompted much discussion. According to this blog article hakia has initiated a second "Search for Better Search" conversation with these critical and debated issues in mind. I covered the first version of these conversations back in May after a great talk with Melek who went to great lengths to help me understand their complex technology. […]

Hakia, busca significado	October 6th, 2007 at 10:37 am
[…] Copias parciales deben citar la fuente. Sociable: Digg \| Menéame \| del.icio.us \| Fresqui \| Mister Wong Tags: buscador hakia Categorías: Reviews y Opinión Entradasrelacionadas: […]

Benjamin Baudouin blog » Blog Archive » 2007. Innover pour chercher mieux

November 19th, 2007 at 1:33 pm

(翻译中) 搜索引擎-17个Google不具有的创新功能 | 站长工具箱

February 9th, 2008 at 5:10 am

Hakia Awarded Webware 100 Honors

April 22nd, 2008 at 6:14 am

[…] One conversation Riza and I had revealed a search vision that is quite unlike anything we experience now on the Web. I wont be giving away and secrets I hope when I tell you that a refined form of artificial intelligence is quite possible. Imagine a search engine capable of actually helping the user solve problems or find searches in a much more efficient way. Search is what we do on the Web, and discovering unique and effective ways of gathering and displaying data is what hakia is all about. […]

Comments

BillyWarhol

May 2nd, 2007 at 12:12 pm

Interesting Phil!

I’m always amazed how i’ll see something on CNN or in the Newspaper & try & search their sites for more info & not even being able to Find anything!! Mind-boggling that CNN don’t have at least Google for Searching their site* They must be using some lame Microsoft product!!

;PPP

Phil Butler

May 2nd, 2007 at 2:26 pm

Hi Billy,
Thanks a lot man! Yes, we tend to “accept” a great deal that is mediocre in life. I would like to apologize to you and all my readers for the slight flaws in this article, I was up until 4 am because I really wanted to share this interesting news with you all.
I was so focused on explaining how this marvelous technology will impact us that me editing slumped on me.
Ultimately, this is one of those subjects where the “idea” overrides the form. I think I did a fair job of explaining in less than 1000 words, years of in depth study and work. Whew!

digitalnomad

May 2nd, 2007 at 3:10 pm

Sounds like a lofty project. I had to scan this and will return. Certainly Google will not be the last word in search engines. Have you seen the articles about Wiki starting an engine?

I squinted at your graphic…is that the 300 Spartans?

Phil Butler	May 2nd, 2007 at 5:37 pm
Yes Nomad, I interviewed Jimmy Wales some time back and have written a few on it myself. Interesting innovations these search entities.

Svetlana Gladkova	May 3rd, 2007 at 1:54 am
Nomad: here is the link to Jimmy Wales interview here on Profy, I think you might find it interesting http://www.profy.com/2007/03/12/wales-interview/.

The Software Abstractions Blog

May 7th, 2007 at 1:26 am

Top 17 Search Innovations outside of Google…

digg_url = ‘http://blog.softwareabstractions.com/the_software_abstractions/2007/05/top_17_search_i.html’; There is an abundance of new search engines (100 at last count ) - each pioneering some innovation in search technology. Here is a list of the …

.NET on the Operating Table

May 20th, 2007 at 3:41 pm

Move over Googling, enter hakiaing ?…

On May 15th, Rediff carried an article on Who are the Google Killers? - it picked two of the challengers to Google’s Search……

私服	August 1st, 2007 at 9:54 pm
Website?

Vinay	October 9th, 2007 at 4:06 pm
Hakia is a bit different from the usual search engines. I hope it will establish itself. I’ve also blogged about it here: http://desinotes.com/semantic-search-technology-of-hakia/

Hakia - Search for Better Search

Trackbacks

Comments

Post a comment

Send to a friend